A Culture of Cheating?

A companion piece to A Culture of Propaganda?

by Lawrence Davidson edited by O Society March 11, 2020

Part I: Cheating as a Perennial Problem

Celebs Ringside at Floyd Mayweather vs Arturo Gatti - WBC Lightweight Title Fight - June 25, 2005

Cheating – and the lying which is its constant companion – is probably as old as the human species. Not coincidentally, this is probably also how long we have known these traits to be  undesirable in our fellow human beings.

The Ninth Commandment tells us not to bear false witness against our neighbor, which can be interpreted broadly as an imperative not to lie, and specifically not to do so in a legal context, such as to commit perjury.


Most older societies assigned someone to monitor the marketplace for reliable weights and measures because left to themselves, most capitalists – of all times and places – value profit and will cheat to get it. This reality is confirmed by the Roman warning caveat emptor (let the buyer beware).

This perennial problem is still with us and can be held at bay by education, regulation, and standards set by role models and other worthy authority figures. Alas, these standards slipped in the case of not only the so-called “Holy” Roman Empire of yesterday, but also the tech-amplified arena of the United States of today; thus, our tendency to cheat entered an exponential growth phase.


Here are just a few of the recent real-world examples:

(1) The Astros baseball team cheated to win the World Series in the 2017 season. Baseball is the “national sport” of the United States and as such, it is supposed to hold an honorable place in our culture. But did it stop what must have been nearly the entire Astros team (every batter must have been in on the scheme) from involving themselves in the “game plan” to steal their opponents’ pitching signs? Not at all.


Lori Loughlin stars in Terms of Entitlement

(2) Then we were shown how willing numerous well-to-do Americans are to suborn the college entrance process by buying their children into elite schools. The educational system in the United States is supposedly a mark of national pride, and so is the status of wealth. So why shouldn’t the latter assure entrance into the former? To make it so, all one has to do is cheat (in these cases bribery is the vehicle).


Joe Biden Admits Plagiarism in Law School, Says It’s No Big Deal

(3) And, by the way, students in colleges and universities, high-end schools or otherwise, can engage in the cheating process by plagiarizing. Term papers and other pre-prepared, and illicit, assignments are for sale online.

Here in the U.S., we are no longer sure all of this is really so bad. Maybe, if you can get away with it, it is just smart. This is the message the public receives from an increasing number of traditional role models; those who now stand at the very highest levels of our society publicly flaunt corruption.


The Birth of Fuckery: How To Think About Donald Trump’s Lies

I speak here of the behavior of President Donald Trump (and his entourage), who, in less than three years in office managed to brandish his particular aptitude for mendacity (the man is a habitual liar by any standard), bribery, obstruction, incitement, and just plain disdain for all manner of rules. And this behavior gives license to others to act out their own disregard for both honesty and truth.

All of this is very bad news. This cheating side of our behavior, after  it gained increased acceptance, became a real threat to two basic pillars of our society: the integrity of science/ technology and the practice of honest government.


Part II—Cheating as a Societal Threat: The Erosion of Science

Let’s begin with science and technology. Our society would be unrecognizable apart from the science and technology that underpins all material aspects of modern life. The scientific method is the surest way we know to establish the truth about aspects of the material world. Yet today, this foundation is in a process of relentless erosion by the lies and misrepresentations that plague our everyday lives.

How is this being done? According to the Union of Concerned Scientists, the Trump administration, in its rush to do away with all manner of regulations, considers scientific observations as obstacles to be overcome. This is particularly the case when it comes to the “active dismantling science-based health and safety protections, sidelining scientific evidence, and undoing recent progress” based on scientific research. Here are just a few of dozens of examples:

(1) Trump appointed administrators at the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) have “forbidden SACC [that is, its own Scientific Advisory Committee on Chemicals] from commenting” on EPA decisions concerning such things as worker safety protections, cancer risks, and the (often suspect) quality of industry data.

(2) The Department of the Interior (DOI) “dismantled the role of science” when looking at protections for endangered and threatened species.

(3) The Department of Agriculture (USDA) prevented the release of a plan for how the agency can effectively respond to the impacts of climate change.

(4) Donald Trump issued an Executive Order to “rid federal agencies of one-third of their advisory committees,” many of which provide scientific advice to federal agencies.

Without proper scientific standards for review and regulation, we get what David Michaels, former Assistant Secretary of Labor for the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, (OSHA), calls “mercenary science.”

This is “science-for-hire, contracted out by chemical and pharmaceutical companies to ‘prove’ their harmful products aren’t harmful by giving them the quantitative imprimatur.”

This is what happens given inadequately supervised capitalism, where science and truth are separated out for the sake of profit. Before proper regulation, this approach killed and maimed millions of consumers throughout human history. It will do so again as Trump deregulates.


Clinton Campaign Renews Attacks with Photos of Obama in “Kenyan Muslim” Garb

Part III—Cheating as a Social Threat: The Erosion of Honest Government

A popular sense those who run the U.S. government are not trustworthy, and do not run the government in the interests of the nation as a whole, is not new. According to multiple polls taken regularly since the end of World War II, this sentiment became prevalent in the 1960s, and persists ever since.

NY Times Finally Corrects Hillary Clinton’s Lie About 17 Intelligence Agencies Being Certain of Her Russiagate Claims

It is also interesting this downturn in confidence in U.S. leadership coincides with the upturn of a culture war still being waged today. In the 1960s, it was the alienating and starkly immoral nature of the Vietnam War that gave impetus to a youth counterculture movement. Also in the 1960s the various aspects of an African-American power movement—ranging from the actions of Martin Luther King to those of the Black Panthers—began to promote politically effective equalitarianism.

Therefore, one should not be surprised a good part of Donald Trump’s “base” is a reactionary force in this war: white, racist, and culturally traditionalist.


As to the last of these positions, many of Trump’s backers are religious ideologues who wage a societal war against same-sex marriage and other LGBTQ civil rights protections. These are the same “Godly” folks who think evolution is wrong and science a suspect anti-religious enterprise.

Simultaneously, these believers turn a blind eye to Trump’s criminal inclinations. These people will support him because he is a tool, albeit a lying and cheating one, in some imagined genocidal divine plan.

Joe Biden: Salesman for “Weapons of Mass Destruction” Lies and Iraq Invasion

However, the cheating culture we are now confronted with does not express itself through Trump and his supporters alone. As we see, it is wider ranging, perhaps ubiquitous.

So, while the actions of certain Democrats may not openly match Donald Trump in crudeness and venality, you can be certain these Democrats also undermine honest, representative government.

Democratic Party cheating became notable in 2012. No doubt it goes back much further, but 2012 is when it literally showed itself nationwide on public media.

Specifically, the telltale incident occurred on Wednesday, the 5th of September, 2012—in the middle of a broadcasted session of the Democratic Party convention, no less!


Here is how it went down:

—The Democratic platform committee decided to keep all issues pertaining to a final treaty between Israelis and Palestinians out of the platform. After all, Israel and Palestine are foreign nations. Among these issues is the final status of the city of Jerusalem.

—However, the Republican platform of that year “envisioned” Israel with Jerusalem as its capital, and the Republicans were trying to make the status of Jerusalem a campaign issue.

—So, President Obama and his platform committee decided the politically expedient thing to do was to change the Democratic platform to match that of the Republicans.

—However, to amend the platform required a two-thirds majority vote from the convention floor. So Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, who was chairing the Democratic convention, confidently called for a voice vote on the issue.

—Villaraigosa called for the vote three times. Each time the viewer could hear that he failed to get the desired result. Between the second and third vote a member of the platform committee went over and told Villaraigosa that he had to rule in favor of the change in wording. So, after the third vote, which again could be heard to fall short of the two-thirds required, Villaraigosa straight out lied and said the delegates had approved the change in wording, and that was that.

This brazen incident, taking place on national television, was not the last time the Democratic leadership cheated. They rigged the selection process in favor of Hillary Clinton in 2016 and may even now be rigging the selection process against Senators Sanders and Warren in 2020. Also, some Democratic “progressives” are showing signs of being vicious competitors in their own right.

Obama Drinks Glass of Filtered Water in Flint Michigan Claims Local Water is Safe to Drink

Part IV—Conclusion

Cheating, along with its partner habitual lying, undermines both communities and institutions: everything from marriage to commerce, to science, to government. Nothing can stand firm before them once these vices become normative. That is what makes Donald Trump so unacceptable—he represents a social climate wherein honesty can never be assumed.

Once again, it should be emphasized Trump, as dangerous as he certainly is, did not cause this present problem. He is just opportunistically exploiting it. In truth, these vices are always latent within society because, for human beings, cheating rather than honesty may be a default position. Thus, we must be taught or otherwise encouraged to be honest with both each other and ourselves.

Girlfriend discovering that her boyfriend is cheating

Donald Trump Finally Admits Barack Obama was Born in the US

This is not just a lesson for parents, schools, the courts, and the marketplace. It is also a necessary lesson for our politics. But we have not managed to come up with a way to vet our leaders so as to assure their long-term honesty and integrity—a process we have been searching for since the time of Plato. Nonetheless, we should try harder, because both history (of which most people are woefully ignorant) and our present circumstances offer us examples of what it means to fail in this regard. Cheating and the habitual lying that comes with it are the ultimate signs of systems failure.

2 thoughts on “A Culture of Cheating?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s