When Your Governing Principle is “Owning the Libitards”

What if his moral compass only points to antagonizing the people who didn’t vote for him?

by Tom Socca edited by O Society September 10, 2019

Fine: Donald Trump wanted to buy Greenland, or at least wanted to talk about wanting to buy Greenland. Presidents are allowed to be silly and imperialist; taking over Greenland is mild stuff compared with, say, planting a flag on the moon.

trump on toilet

The original Wall Street Journal story to break the news of Trump’s desire contains one truly alarming passage, and apparently it is supposed to be reassuring: One of the Journal’s sources said the president’s interest in buying Greenland is probably not “a serious inquiry,” because “Trump hasn’t floated the idea at a campaign rally yet.

This—like the rapid melting of the Arctic makes Greenland an attractive future acquisition—is simply a background fact: If the president of the United States is serious about doing something, he will announce it at a campaign rally.

There are many recurring themes to help explain what’s happening in the United States under Donald Trump: incompetence, cruelty,racism, self-dealing, misogyny. Yet the perpetual campaign rally gives shape to all the others. The Trump presidency is the result of politics organized around unending partisan aggression, which drove out even the pretense of other aims. The only goal of power in the Trump era is to own the libitards.

Owning the libs is the purpose behind an otherwise purposeless policy agenda. Why would the administration roll back methane emission limits and fuel-efficiency restrictions, when the power and automotive industries have asked it not to? Why would it go to the trouble of announcing restrictions that would make it harder for a small fraction of members of the armed forces to get citizenship for their children? Why force a losing legal battle on adding a citizenship question to the census?


“As president,” Eric Levitz wrote in New York magazine last week, “Trump shows a singular disinterest in appealing to—or showing even the smallest bit of deference to the interests of—those outside his party’s coalition.” Levitz was responding to the Trump’s expressions of contempt for Puerto Rico, as another hurricane closed in on the island, and to a Trump-Pence fundraising email declaring, of the Democrats, “this is our country, not theirs.”

liberals-crying-morning.jpgIt’s true, Donald Trump has no interest in actually acting as president of the entire country. At most, he gestures toward the idea of making the country so rich and so proud the people who’ve been against him will eventually have to submit to him in gratitude. But the us-versus-them message is not just an expression of Trump’s individual personality defects—rather, Trump is president because his personality defects harmonize with the political movement already in control of his party.

Last month, Kentucky Gov. Matt Bevin dropped by the Kentucky Democratic Party’s booth at the state fair. For the occasion, Bevin was wearing a bright blue-and-white blazer printed all over with images of Donald Trump’s face. Matt Bevin was elected in November 2015, before Trump had even won the Republican nomination for president.

It’s notable—though far from dispositive—  Democratic booth staffers disputed news reports calling the governor’s visit “trolling,” saying instead they had a “nice long conversation.” The Trump regalia, then, was part of what passes for the everyday order of business. It was normal, for people who live in Kentucky, that the governor of their state, performing his ceremonial duties at a century-old event for the full citizenry, should choose to make himself a billboard for the president’s face.

In the same way, it’s normal for Bevin to be fighting a running court battle to try to force hundreds of thousands of people off Medicaid, because Medicaid expansion is part of the Affordable Care Act, and the Affordable Care Act is a win for the Democrats.

It’s just the team he’s on.


In the permanent campaign rally, the point of governing is to let everyone know who’s who. This is why Ken Cuccinelli, the acting head of Citizenship and Immigration Services and another figure whose taste for partisan warfare predates Trump, gloated on Twitter about the work his office was doing to block immigration, writing “the best is yet to come!” It’s why when pressed about the poem at the foot of the Statue of Liberty, the tired and the poor and so on, he disavowed the message—just as Stephen Miller, the baleful engineer of the administration’s anti-immigrant machinery, had disavowed it two years before. The ruling party has no use for the Statue of Liberty, because the Statue of Liberty is understood to belong to everyone.


This has been developing for a long time: Next year will be the 25th anniversary of the government shutdown led by Newt Gingrich, when the speaker of the House decided it was better to disable the day-to-day operations of the country than to cooperate with a Democratic president. At the time, it was understood to be a showdown between one governing agenda and another.

In the intervening years, though, the deed itself became the point, an act of pure negation. By 2013, when the Tea Party and Ted Cruz shut down the government, the purpose was simply to sabotage the Affordable Care Act—not to produce any alternative policy but to try to use control of a single house of Congress to nullify what was already made law.

Some might gullibly take the Tea Party for a group with identifiable policy priorities. But the Tea Party yells about fiscal restraint because it wants to restrain a Democratic president from being able to spend money. When a Republican gets into the White House, the budgetary restraint goes away.

How the Right Wing Uses the Two Santa Clauses Tactic to Con America for Forty Years


Opposition is the only principle. Eventually, inexorably, this leads to the moment Mitch McConnell simply refuses to consider any Supreme Court nominee Barack Obama might nominate—followed by John McCain declaring his intention to block any potential nomination made by a President Hillary Clinton, as well. The alternative to a Republican justice is be no justice at all.

And a broken government is better than a shared one. In Trump, the party found a figure who frees it from even pretending to care about running the country. Where the George W. Bush administration boasted “when we act, we create our own reality,” the Trump administration dispenses with action and reality alike.

The Reality-Based Community


Every decision or announcement or tweet is pure antagonism, a boast of a win built on taunting the losers. By the time anyone tries to figure out what happened—whether the wording of the executive order makes legal sense, or the draft memo ever came to be, or where anybody put the detained babies—the president  got bored and moved on. The insight of Donald Trump and the people around him, then, is the spirit of negation is not just for obstructing what your opponents want to do, but can extend to the entire project of being in charge of the government.


If you’re weak enough to care, by the way, the Federal Election Commission just joined the list of disabled institutions, with one of its four existing commissioners—out of a body supposed to have six—resigning at the end of August. This leaves it without a quorum and therefore unable to enforce election law.

The vacancies are there because the Trump administration abandoned the traditional practice of filling the seats two at a time, by naming one Republican and one Democratic nominee. Instead it submitted a single name, a former Trump campaign lawyer. The libs have been owned.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s